
Woodstock Way Hotel
Best for town access, designed rooms, and a compact boutique hotel experience with on‑site coffee and easy walking to restaurants and galleries.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Woodstock Way Hotel is an eco‑luxe boutique hotel in downtown Woodstock built around a 15‑foot waterfall; read this if you want a polished, walkable Woodstock base with on‑site coffee bar and light amenities. The Old Catskill Game Farm Inn is a small, themed inn on the former Catskill Game Farm grounds in Catskill—this guide is for travelers drawn to a distinctive, historic game‑farm setting and rustic outdoor amenities.
Updated

Best for town access, designed rooms, and a compact boutique hotel experience with on‑site coffee and easy walking to restaurants and galleries.

Best for a quirky Catskills stay on historic game‑farm grounds with outdoor private hot tubs, rustic outdoor spaces and lots of on‑site outdoor activities.
When Woodstock Way Hotel wins: choose Woodstock Way if you want a walkable downtown Woodstock location, artistically designed rooms (turntables and vinyl), reliable front‑desk hours and easy access to town dining, galleries and nearby swimming holes.
When The Old Catskill Game Farm Inn wins: pick the Game Farm Inn for a small, off‑town destination with themed room names, outdoor private hot tubs, sauna and wide on‑site outdoor activity options—if you want a stay defined by the property’s unusual history and grounds.
Bottom line: Both properties offer memorable Catskills stays but for different reasons—Woodstock Way is a polished town‑center boutique; The Old Catskill Game Farm Inn is a small, destination property on former game‑farm land with strong outdoor amenities.
| Category | Woodstock Way Hotel | The Old Catskill Game Farm Inn |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Eco‑luxe boutique centered on a 15‑ft waterfall; artist‑curated rooms and a communal coffee lounge | Small, quirky inn on historic Catskill Game Farm grounds with rustic outdoor spaces |
| Location | Downtown Woodstock, steps from Tinker Street and Catskill State Park | Rural Catskill address at 400 Game Farm Rd (on former game‑farm property) |
| Size (approx.) | 23–25 uniquely designed accommodations (treehouses, cabins, rooms) | 9 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Ages / policy | All ages welcome; family‑friendly (children 12 and under stay free when sharing a room with a paying adult) | All ages welcome (adultsOnly: false) |
| Pools & water | No on‑site pool; about an 8‑minute walk to Millstream Swimming Hole (natural swimming spot) | Some rooms feature outdoor private hot tubs; no on‑site pool listed |
| Restaurants & bars | The Tannery: on‑site coffee bar and light snacks (no full restaurant) | Not published |
| Wellness / spa | On‑site massage services by advance reservation (limited spa services) | Sauna listed among on‑site amenities |
| Known for | 15‑foot waterfall, vinyl turntables in rooms, walkable Woodstock location | Location on the former Catskill Game Farm grounds and themed room names |
| Parking & access | Free on‑site parking; limited front‑desk hours (The Tannery) so arrive in posted hours or call ahead | Free self parking, free RV/bus/truck parking, secured and fully fenced parking |
| Meeting & events | Multiple small indoor/outdoor venues and full‑property buyout option (up to 60 guests) | Number of meeting rooms - 1 listed; wedding services available |
Woodstock Way Hotel sits steps from Tinker Street and downtown Woodstock attractions.
Choose Woodstock Way for a central, walkable Woodstock stay and easy access to town life.
The Old Catskill Game Farm Inn occupies grounds of the former Catskill Game Farm in Catskill.
Pick the Game Farm Inn if you want a stay defined by the property and outdoor grounds rather than town walking.
Rooms at Woodstock Way range from compact to multi‑bed residences and often include in‑room turntables and heated floors.
Woodstock Way focuses on curated design touches and a range of room sizes for couples and families.
The Old Catskill Game Farm Inn has a small set of themed guestrooms named after animals and larger house options.
The Game Farm Inn is for travelers who want playful, themed rooms and more self‑contained lodging options.
Woodstock Way keeps food service light and local-focused through The Tannery.
Expect café‑style offerings on site and walkable restaurant choices nearby.
Supplier listing does not publish a signature on‑site restaurant for The Old Catskill Game Farm Inn.
Plan meals in advance—some units have kitchens, and outdoor grilling is available on site.
Woodstock Way's signature water feature is its 15‑foot waterfall and garden; the property does not have an on‑site pool.
The waterfall and outdoor patio are the hotel's main water‑related attractions—swimming requires a short walk off property.
The Old Catskill Game Farm Inn highlights outdoor private hot tubs in some guestrooms and many outdoor recreation options.
If a private outdoor hot tub and extensive outdoor programming are priorities, the Game Farm Inn is a stronger fit.
Woodstock Way offers on‑site massage services by appointment and a calm evening scene around the waterfall and lawn.
Choose Woodstock Way for a low‑key, design‑forward stay with booked massage options and quiet evenings.
The Old Catskill Game Farm Inn provides a sauna and a range of outdoor recreation options on the property.
The Game Farm Inn suits guests who prioritize outdoor wellness features and on‑property activity access.

Woodstock Way Hotel — steps from Tinker Street shops, galleries and dining.

The Old Catskill Game Farm Inn — a stay defined by its former game‑farm grounds and themed rooms.

Woodstock Way Hotel — multiple small indoor/outdoor venues and full‑property buyout for up to ~60 guests.

The Old Catskill Game Farm Inn — rooms with outdoor private hot tubs, firepit and extensive outdoor amenity list.
Woodstock Way is better for dining out because it’s in downtown Woodstock within easy walking distance to many restaurants; The Old Catskill Game Farm Inn has limited on‑site food service listed, so plan to cook or drive for meals.
No—both properties welcome guests of all ages; Woodstock Way explicitly welcomes children and lets children 12 and under stay free when sharing a room with a paying adult.
The Old Catskill Game Farm Inn lists outdoor private hot tubs in some guestrooms; Woodstock Way does not list private hot tubs.
Woodstock Way offers on‑site massage services by advance reservation but not a full spa; The Old Catskill Game Farm Inn lists a sauna among its amenities.
Explore how Woodstock Way Hotel stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·